Will I lose my original citizenship if I naturalize as a U.S. citizen?
Not under U.S. law — the United States recognizes dual citizenship and does not require renunciation, but your country of origin may have its own rules that revoke citizenship upon naturalization elsewhere.
The Oath of Allegiance taken at the naturalization ceremony includes a renunciation of "all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state, or sovereignty." That language is symbolic, not operative under U.S. law: the State Department has long held (see 7 FAM 1200) that the U.S. does not require a naturalized citizen to formally renounce other citizenships, and dual citizenship is fully recognized.
What the United States actually cares about
- You owe primary allegiance to the United States. That means using your U.S. passport for U.S. entry, paying U.S. taxes on worldwide income, and complying with U.S. military registration where applicable.
- You may serve in a foreign military or accept foreign employment without losing U.S. citizenship, unless you do so with intent to relinquish U.S. citizenship (the Vance v. Terrazas standard).
What your country of origin may do
The rules vary widely:
- Mexico — permits dual nationality and does not revoke Mexican nationality upon U.S. naturalization (since the 1998 constitutional amendment).
- El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Colombia, Peru, Ecuador, Argentina, Chile, Brazil — all permit dual nationality.
- India — does not permit dual citizenship, but offers Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) status which provides most practical benefits.
- China (PRC) — does not recognize dual nationality; voluntary naturalization elsewhere triggers loss of PRC nationality, but enforcement is inconsistent.
- Philippines — permits dual nationality (Republic Act 9225) for those who acquired foreign citizenship through naturalization.
- Vietnam, Japan, South Korea, Singapore — generally do not permit dual citizenship for adults, though exceptions exist.
The practical tax issue
U.S. citizens are taxed on worldwide income under the Internal Revenue Code, regardless of residence. A dual citizen living abroad still files U.S. returns (often with foreign earned income exclusion and foreign tax credits to avoid double taxation). The FBAR (FinCEN Form 114) and FATCA Form 8938 disclosure obligations also apply. New citizens should expect to file U.S. returns indefinitely.
Travel as a dual citizen
- Enter and exit the U.S. on your U.S. passport. Required under 22 C.F.R. § 53.1.
- Enter and exit your other country on that country's passport where it is required.
- Many dual citizens carry both passports on every trip.
How we handle this
For clients who care about the dual-citizenship analysis we provide a country-specific briefing before filing the N-400, citing the home-country statute and consular practice. Where the home country has formal revocation rules, we coordinate with home-country counsel so the client can decide knowingly. The Oath itself is straightforward; the consequences abroad are where attention is needed.
Frequently asked questions
Is an RFE the same as a case denial?
No, an RFE is not a denial. It is a formal request for more information that the officer needs to make a decision. If you provide the requested evidence properly, your case can still be approved.
How long do I have to respond to a marriage green card RFE?
The deadline is listed on the RFE notice itself, usually ranging from 30 to 87 days. You must ensure your response is received by USCIS on or before that specific date to avoid a denial.
Can I submit my RFE response in multiple mailings?
No, you should submit all requested documents in one single package. USCIS generally only reviews the first response they receive for an RFE, so sending partial information can lead to a rejection.
What happens if I cannot find the specific document USCIS requested?
If a primary document like a birth certificate is unavailable, you must provide a certificate of non-availability from the government and submit secondary evidence. This might include school records, census records, or affidavits from people who have personal knowledge of the event.
Legal sources
- INA § 316 — Naturalization requirements — INA § 316 · 8 U.S.C. § 1427